Court Rejects Challenge to New Ethanol Fuel Blendposted: 8/28/2012
“Before we even consider the merits of the petitions, we must determine whether any petitioner has standing to bring them to court,” Chief Judge David Sentelle wrote in his opinion.
Each industry group had advanced a theory of standing, but none was adequate to meet the burden of established standing, Sentelle wrote.
“Because we hold that no petitioner has standing to bring this action, we dismiss all petitions for lack of jurisdiction.”
The National Marine Manufacturers Association (NMMA), which represents the recreational boating industry in North America, issued a statement saying “this decision puts the potentially dangerous E-15 at gas pumps across the country -- a troubling scenario for American boaters and the recreational boating industry.
“While the decision is a setback, it does not speak to the underlying merits of the case -- whether EPA was in fact correct in its interpretation of the Clean Air Act to allow for a partial waiver in the first case,” the NMMA said.
Judge Brett Kavanaugh, who dissented from the three-judge panel’s decision, said that he would have granted the petition for review and vacated the EPA’s E-15 waiver decision.
In his dissent, Kavanaugh wrote that in granting the E-15 partial waiver, EPA “ran roughshod over the relevant statutory limits.” The EPA waiver, he said, “is flatly contrary to the plain text of the statute.”
Late in 2011, the EPA approved the use of E-15 for a subset of on-highway motor vehicles (model years 2001-2006). Earlier that same year, the EPA approved the use of E-15 for model year 2007 and newer vehicles, as part of its response to a waiver petition filed in the spring of 2009 by the pro-ethanol lobbying group Growth Energy.
The partial waiver excluded marine engines and other non-road engines, such as snowmobiles, and lawn and garden equipment.
The NMMA said that, because it is concerned that the waiver will lead to widespread misfueling by consumers, it has, at its own expense, distributed labels for the marine industry to warn against fueling marine engines with E-15.
NMMA president Thom Dammrich said that the EPA had approved E-15 in violation of its clear statutory requirements.
“NMMA will continue to evaluate and address policy to protect boaters from misfueling and product failures associated with incompatible fuels, and will take the necessary actions to ensure compatible fuels remain available and affordable,” Dammrich said.